Episode 88: Why Do I Handle Money the Way I Do? Understanding Money Scripts

Hosts: Madison Demora and Mike Garry

Episode Overview

Why do you handle money the way you do? The answer may come from money scripts, the beliefs about money we pick up as kids and often carry into adulthood without realizing it. In this episode of Not Just Numbers, just in time for Thanksgiving, Madison and Mike walk through the four money scripts: money avoidance, money worship, money status and money vigilance. They talk about how early these beliefs form, why so many families still avoid talking about money, and what happens when parents never discuss an inheritance with their children. They also share an easy way to notice money patterns at your own holiday table, and how understanding them can make your financial plan work better for you.

Listen to Our Podcast On:

TIMESTAMPS

00:08 – 04:07 – Introduction: What Are Money Scripts?

04:08 – 08:13 – The Four Money Scripts Explained

08:14 – 12:30 – How Family Shapes Our Money Beliefs and Conversations

12:31 – 19:39 – Money Scripts, the Great Wealth Transfer, and Family Financial Habits

19:40 – 23:29 – How Money Scripts Affect Financial Planning & Key Takeaways

Follow Us on Social Media

Stay updated with the latest episodes and news by following us on social media:

 

Episode Glossary

  • Money Scripts: Unconscious beliefs about money that typically develop during childhood and influence how individuals save, spend, invest, and discuss finances throughout their lives.

Key Takeaways

  • Money scripts are unconscious beliefs about money that usually form early in life. They can shape how you spend, save, invest and talk about money, even when they have little to do with your situation today.
  • Research by financial psychologist Brad Klontz grouped these beliefs into four patterns: money avoidance, money worship, money status and money vigilance. Most people have a mix of them.
  • Money avoidance and money worship were both linked to lower net worth. Money status was linked to overspending and credit card debt, and was the only script tied to growing up with financial struggles.
  • Money vigilance often looks healthy (careful, frugal, consistent savers), but it can come with ongoing anxiety and difficulty enjoying what you’ve saved.
  • Kids learn about money by watching the adults around them. Stress over bills, or never talking about money at all, can teach lessons parents don’t mean to teach.
  • Many parents never tell their children what they may inherit. If you have hopes for how an inheritance will be used, your children can’t know unless you talk about it.
  • This Thanksgiving, try noticing how your family reacts when money comes up, rather than talking about dollar amounts. Awareness is the first step to understanding your own financial decisions.

Transcript

Not Just Numbers: Honest Conversations with a Financial Advisor and Lawyer
Episode 88 – Why Do I Handle Money the Way I Do? Understanding Money Scripts

Introduction: What Are Money Scripts?

Madison: Hello everyone and welcome to Not Just Numbers, Honest Conversations with a Financial Advisor and Lawyer, the official podcast of Yardley Wealth Management. I am Madison Demora and I’m here with Mike Garry. Mike is a financial advisor and a CFP practitioner and the founder and the CEO of Yardley Wealth Management. He is also an estate planning lawyer and his law firm is Yardley Estate Planning. Hey Mike.

Mike: Hey Maddie, how are you?

Madison: I’m good. How are you doing today?

Mike: Good. Beautiful day out there.

Madison: Yes, it is. Beautiful fall day. Love it. So with this fall season coming, Thanksgiving is coming up, a lot of families will be gathering around the table. And for some, that means having three generations together, all with different perspectives, experiences, and opinions. One topic that might come up, or might be intentionally avoided, is money. And what’s interesting is that the way we think about money today may have much more to do with how we grew up than we realize. There’s actually a term for this in financial psychology called a money script. Mike, before we get into the different types, what exactly is a money script, and why should people care about understanding theirs?

Mike: All right. So a money script is essentially an unconscious belief about money that usually develops early in life and continues to influence how we handle our finances as adults. These beliefs can affect how we spend, save, invest, and even how comfortable we feel discussing money with other people. The interesting thing is that most people don’t even realize they’re acting on these beliefs. They just assume that’s how they’re supposed to handle money. And sometimes, those beliefs have very little to do with their actual financial situation today.

Madison: So somebody could be financially secure, but still have certain anxieties or habits around money because of what they experienced growing up.

Mike: Exactly. And that’s why understanding these beliefs is so important. Financial decisions aren’t always based on numbers, you know, it’s not just numbers, right? Our experience and emotions play a significant role, too.

Madison: All right. So let’s talk about where this idea came from. Financial psychologist Brad Klontz and three co-researchers surveyed 422 adults about 72 different beliefs surrounding money. Some of those beliefs included statements like “money is the root of all evil” or “you can never have enough money.” They eventually grouped the responses into four different patterns. What did this research reveal about the connection between our beliefs and our financial behavior?

Mike: So the research showed that people tend to develop certain patterns in how they think about money, and those patterns can help explain their financial behavior. The four categories they identified were money avoidance, money worship, money status, and money vigilance. What’s important to understand is these aren’t necessarily conscious decisions. Someone may consistently avoid looking at their finances or feel uncomfortable spending money, even when they can afford to, without recognizing the underlying belief driving that behavior.

Madison: And we’re not necessarily just one of these four types, right? We could have characteristics of several?

Mike: Correct. Yeah, it would be it would be pretty strange for somebody to just have one, right? The research found that most people have some combination of these scripts. For example, someone could be extremely careful about everyday expenses but still feel they need to drive an expensive car because they associate it with success. Those behaviors might seem contradictory, but they could both make sense when you understand the underlying beliefs.

Madison: So it’s less about putting yourself into one category and more about recognizing patterns in your financial decisions.

Mike: Exactly. The purpose is really to become more aware of why you’re making certain financial decisions.

The Four Money Scripts Explained

Madison: All right. So let’s break down these four money scripts individually, because I think people listening might recognize some of these behaviors in themselves or even in a family member. Let’s start with money avoidance. What does that look like?

Mike: So money avoidance is the belief that money is somehow bad, dangerous, or morally questionable. Someone with this mindset might feel guilty about having money or uncomfortable discussing it. In some cases, those beliefs can lead people to undermine their own financial efforts.

Madison: So even if someone has the ability to improve their financial situation, their beliefs about money might prevent them from doing so?

Mike: Yeah, we see that all the time. You know, in the original research, money avoidance was associated with both lower income and lower net worth. And it doesn’t mean everyone with those beliefs will struggle financially, but it shows how our attitudes can influence our behavior.

Madison: The second category is money worship, which sounds almost like the opposite of avoidance.

Mike: In some ways, yes. You know, money worship is the belief that having more money will solve your problems or make you happier. Fun fact, it doesn’t. The problem is that the amount someone believes they need may keep increasing. They might earn more, but then still feel dissatisfied, or maybe believe that the next financial milestone will finally make them happy. We see this all the time with prospects where couples have had struggled with finances, and you know they get in here and you know they have never worked with an advisor and they’re making an amount that they couldn’t believe they would ever make like in the past. And still can’t understand where all the money’s going, and like, oh, what’s going on, and yeah, it leads to problems. You know, the research also found that money worship had a particularly strong association with lower net worth.

Madison: And it can lead to overspending because someone is constantly pursuing that sense of satisfaction?

Mike: Yeah. More money doesn’t necessarily change the underlying belief that you don’t have enough.

Madison: That’s right. The third script is money status. How is that different from money worship?

Mike: So money status is more about connecting your financial success to your personal worth. Someone might feel that having a certain income, owning particular things, or appearing financially successful determines how other people perceive them. And there was an interesting finding in the research. Money status is the only one of the four scripts linked to childhood financial circumstances. People who grew up in households that experienced financial struggles were more likely to develop this belief, regardless of what they earned as adults.

Madison: So someone who grew up without much money might later associate expensive purchases or visible wealth with finally being successful?

Mike: Yeah, that’s one way it can show up. And Dr. Klontz has connected this particular belief with overspending and higher credit card debt. When people feel pressured to demonstrate success, that can influence how they use their money.

Madison: And the last one is money vigilance. At first, that sounds like it might actually be a good thing.

Mike: It can be. Money vigilance is associated with being frugal, careful, discreet, and consistently attentive to your finances. People with this script may save regularly and maintain strong financial positions. But there’s another side to it. Even when they’re financially comfortable, they may continue to experience significant anxiety about money.

Madison: So someone could have plenty saved, but still feel guilty spending money or worry constantly that it won’t be enough?

Mike: Exactly. The research didn’t find the same negative association between money vigilance and income or net worth that it found with some of the other scripts. But that doesn’t mean it’s without consequences. Someone can become so focused on protecting their money that they have difficulty enjoying what they’ve worked to accumulate.

Madison: That’s interesting because it shows that having healthy finances and having a healthy relationship with money aren’t necessarily the same thing.

Mike: No, that is an important distinction, Maddie. Very important distinction.

How Family Shapes Our Money Beliefs and Conversations

Madison: All right. One thing that really stood out to me was how early these beliefs develop. A separate study found that by around age seven, children have already developed many of the foundational skills and habits that influence their financial behavior later in life. Mike, how much of our relationship with money is shaped by watching our parents or the adults around us?

Mike: As you can imagine, quite a bit. Children learn by observing how adults behave, often more than by listening to what they’re told. For example, imagine a parent who becomes noticeably stressed whenever a bill arrives. The child might not understand the household’s financial situation, but they can recognize the anxiety associated with money. Or thinking about a family where nobody ever discusses finances. Children may grow up believing that money is private or uncomfortable subject that shouldn’t be talked about.

Madison: And those lessons aren’t necessarily intentional. Parents might not realize they’re teaching their children anything about money through those reactions.

Mike: Exactly. By the time children are old enough to have more direct conversations about saving, spending, or budgeting, they have often already absorbed certain beliefs. And those beliefs can follow them into adulthood. And can be really difficult to shake, if people can shake them.

Madison: So when we talk about teaching children good financial habits, it’s not about explaining what saving means or how to budget. It’s also about the behaviors they’re seeing every day.

Mike: That’s right. Our attitudes and reactions toward money can communicate just as much as the financial lessons we intentionally try to teach.

Madison: All right. Now, let’s bring this back to Thanksgiving. Families can spend hours together talking about work, school, relationships, and everything else that’s going on in their lives. But money is still something many people are uncomfortable discussing. According to a Bankrate survey, only 14% of adults consider money a normal topic of conversation at holiday gatherings. And just 39% feel comfortable discussing their bank account balances with family or close friends. Mike, why do you think money remains such a difficult topic for families?

Mike: So I think the research on money scripts helps explain some of that discomfort. If someone grew up believing that financial matters should always remain private, they’re likely to carry that belief into adulthood. For other people, money might bring up feelings of anxiety, embarrassment, or even comparison with other family members. And sometimes people simply don’t know how to begin the conversation. You know, I hadn’t thought about that until like we’ve been discussing this, but I have like close relationships with family and friends, we never talk about money, never.

Madison: Right.

Mike: It just does not come up. Yeah, and I’m not saying I wouldn’t, but we haven’t so far.

Madison: The survey also found some interesting generational differences. More than half of Gen Z respondents and over 40% of millennials said they were comfortable discussing their account balances. But that dropped to about a third of Gen X respondents. Does that suggest that attitudes towards discussing money may be changing between generations?

Mike: Maybe. The survey certainly suggests there are differences in comfort levels between generations. And that makes sense when we think about how money beliefs develop. Different generations grew up with different experiences and different expectations about what should or shouldn’t be discussed.

Madison: And sometimes, avoiding the conversation might unintentionally teach the generation to avoid it as well.

Mike: Exactly. Silence can be a part of a money script, too. If children constantly see that money is something nobody talks about, that becomes part of what they learn too, right? I mean, makes sense, right?

Madison: But there’s also a difference between keeping certain financial information private and avoiding important conversations altogether, right?

Mike: Yeah, absolutely. There’s nothing wrong with maintaining some privacy around your finances. The concern is when the lack of communication leaves family members completely unaware of important financial matters that may eventually affect them. And that’s especially relevant when we’re talking about passing wealth to the next generation.

Money Scripts, the Great Wealth Transfer, and Family Financial Habits

Madison: That brings us to another important topic: the intergenerational wealth transfer. Because when families pass down wealth, they may also pass down the beliefs and habits surrounding that wealth. A Fidelity Investments Family and Finance Study found that 68% of parents aged 55 and older, with at least five hundred thousand dollars in investable assets haven’t told their adult children what they stand to inherit, or even whether they’ll receive an inheritance. And 52% haven’t discussed their net worth with their children at all. Mike, what stands out to you about those numbers?

Mike: Well, first that they take jibe with our experience too. We talk to people about having communication with their kids and their family members, and you know some people eventually do, but it’s not as common as I think it should be. You know, what really stands out is the lack of communication. We’re talking about families that may eventually transfer significant assets from one generation to another, but many haven’t had the conversations necessary to prepare for that transition. And when you combine that with the money beliefs families have developed over time, it can create some difficult situations.

Madison: Especially if the parents and children have completely different expectations. There was another finding in that Fidelity study that I thought was interesting. 95% of adult children said they felt prepared to manage an inheritance. But 25% of parents disagreed, expressing concerns about how their children would manage the money. What do you make of that disconnect?

Mike: Well, again, it jibes with what I’ve seen. You know, it shows that parents and children don’t necessarily have the same understanding of financial readiness. You know, an adult child may feel perfectly capable of managing inheritance, while a parent has concerns that may have never been discussed. And if those conversations don’t happen, neither side really understands the other’s perspective. I’ve seen a lot of older people in the different generations, you know, I think that they disagree with some financial decisions their kids make. And then make it as if like the child isn’t… Just because the child is doing something different than what the parent has done or would have done, it makes it seem like well the child is not responsible or they make bad choices. And I can say like in my family I think that when I was younger I think that my dad didn’t necessarily always agree with my choices and he probably is surprised that I’ve been as financially successful as I’ve been. But hopefully he listens to this. He probably won’t. Who knows? Anyway, that’s something that is not uncommon, right? For parents to think well their children haven’t learned. Meanwhile, they might trust them with all other things, you know, to physically take care of them, make decisions about their house, their grandkids. But then there’s like this some hang up. There’s hang ups around money, and I think that’s like one of the last things that parents trust their kids with or think they’ll make good decisions.

Madison: So the challenge isn’t necessarily just transferring the assets themselves. It’s also making sure the next generation understands what’s coming and has had an opportunity to discuss it.

Mike: Yep. And this is where those money scripts come into play again. If parents have spent their entire lives believing that money is something private, they may be reluctant to share information with their children. But that silence can leave the next generation making assumptions about something they’ve never discussed. You know, like how can you think that your kids will do a good or bad job with something if you’ve never talked about it. Or if it’s really important for you that your child takes an inheritance and acts a certain way, well, you have to have that conversation or they’re not going to know, right? Like they can’t guess what you want.

Madison: That’s right. Honest conversations, right?

Mike: That’s right.

Madison: And the children might carry that same reluctance into their own families.

Mike: That’s right. That’s why the wealth transfer isn’t exclusively about money. It’s also an opportunity to examine the beliefs and behaviors being passed from one generation to the next.

Madison: So for someone listening who is getting ready to spend Thanksgiving with family, how can they start recognizing some of these money scripts? Because I don’t think we’re suggesting everyone should sit down at Thanksgiving dinner and start asking relatives about their net worth.

Mike: No, you don’t think everybody should come with audited financial statements and net worth statements, income, tax returns?

Madison: I would hope not.

Mike: Definitely not. And that you know that’s actually consistent with what Dr. Brad Klontz suggests, his recommendation is to approach your family almost like a research subject for an afternoon. Pay attention to how people react when the money comes up. Does someone immediately change the subject? Does someone become anxious when discussing a purchase? Does another person associate certain possessions with financial success? Those reactions might tell you something about the beliefs underneath them. Yeah, so pay attention.

Madison: So instead of focusing on the actual dollar amounts, focus on how people respond to the subject of money.

Mike: Yeah. Yeah, because you’re not going to talk about dollar amounts, right? Like you’re not going to say, “Well, how much is in your 401k? What’s the value of your house?” No. The goal isn’t to diagnose your relatives either or to try to change their behavior. It’s just to become more aware of patterns, right? You can see what those patterns are and make better decisions for yourself and your family. That’s the goal.

Madison: Right. There’s also something called a financial genogram. Can you explain what that is?

Mike: Sure. A financial genogram is essentially a family tree that focuses on financial beliefs and behaviors rather than just family relationships. Financial therapists use it to identify patterns that may have been passed down through generations. For example, you might notice that several generations of a family have been extremely cautious about spending money. Or that money has consistently been a topic nobody feels comfortable discussing. The purpose is to recognize how those patterns developed and how they’re affecting people today.

Madison: And someone doesn’t necessarily need to create a formal family tree to start thinking about those patterns.

Mike: Correct. No. Even recognizing a shared behavior and talking about it privately with your spouse afterwards can be useful. The important thing is understanding the belief rather than immediately trying to correct the behavior.

Madison: I think that’s an important point. Because if somebody notices that a family member has a completely different relationship with money, it doesn’t necessarily mean that person is doing something wrong. They may simply be operating from a different set of experiences and beliefs.

Mike: Right. And having that understanding can make financial conversations more productive.

How Money Scripts Affect Financial Planning & Key Takeaways

Madison: All right, let’s bring this into the financial planning process. We talk a lot on this podcast about the importance of having a financial plan, but the plan isn’t just about investments, account balances, and projections. How do these money scripts fit into the work you do with clients?

Mike: You know, financial planning involves behavior just as much as it involves numbers, right? Not just numbers. Someone might have a perfectly reasonable financial strategy on paper, but their beliefs about money can affect whether they’re comfortable following it. For example, someone with a strong money vigilance tendencies might have enough money to support their spending needs but still feel extremely comfortable using their savings. We get that a lot. Another person might consistently overspend because they associate purchases with success or belief that earning more money will eventually solve everything. If you don’t understand those beliefs, you’re only looking at part of the picture.

Madison: So recognizing someone’s money script can help explain why they’re making decisions that might not seem to match their financial circumstances.

Mike: Yep. Sometimes when you understand where a person’s financial habits came from, the behavior makes much more sense. And recognizing those patterns can change the conversation.

Madison: And what about families who are preparing to transfer wealth to their children? How does financial planning help with those conversations?

Mike: You know, one of the things you know we help families think through is how and when to share information with the next generation. That that doesn’t necessarily mean disclosing like every detail immediately. It’s about creating a thoughtful approach to communicating important financial information. The goal is to avoid a situation where inheritance arrives unexpectedly, along with years of assumptions or uncertainty.

Madison: And I imagine those conversations can be very different depending on the family’s history with money.

Mike: Yep. Every family has its own experiences and beliefs. Understanding those differences is an important part of developing a financial strategy that works for the people involved, not just the numbers.

Madison: Mike, if there’s one thing you want listeners to take away from this conversation, what would it be?

Mike: I think it’s that our financial behavior is influenced by more than our income, investments, or account balances. Many of our beliefs about money were formed when we were kids, and we still may be acting on them decades later without realizing it. You know, the more aware we become of those beliefs, the better we can understand our financial decisions. And when it comes to families, recognizing those patterns can also help us have more meaningful conversations about money and what we pass on to the next generation.

Madison: And understanding those beliefs doesn’t mean you have to change everything about how you handle money. It might simply mean recognizing why you feel a certain way about spending, saving, or discussing finances.

Mike: Exactly. Awareness is an important first step.

Madison: As we head into Thanksgiving, it’s interesting to think about how much of our relationship with money may have started around the very same family tables we’re gathering around today. Whether your family openly discusses finances or tends to avoid the subject, those habits and beliefs can influence financial decisions for generations. And as we’ve discussed, the wealth we pass down isn’t the only thing that matters. The attitudes and behaviors surrounding that wealth can be just as influential. Mike, thanks for joining me today.

Mike: Thank you, Madison. It’s been my pleasure.

Madison: Awesome, and thank you everyone for listening. For more information on Yardley Wealth Management or Yardley Estate Planning, you can visit our website at yardleywealth.net and yardleyestate.net. You can also follow us on socials at Yardley Wealth Management. Don’t forget to subscribe to our YouTube channel and smash the like button. This podcast has been produced by Madison Demora and Mike Garry with technical and artistic help from Poe Productions.

Request the Full Transcript as a PDF

The full transcript of this episode is available via email. Please fill out the form below to receive it: