Episode 87: Why Is My Medicare Premium So High? Understanding IRMAA and the Two-Year Lookback

Hosts: Madison Demora and Mike Garry

Episode Overview

Why is your Medicare premium so high? For many new retirees, the answer is Medicare IRMAA, an extra charge based on income from your tax return two years ago, not what you earn today. In this episode of Not Just Numbers, Madison and Mike explain how the two-year lookback works, why someone who just stopped working can still pay a surcharge based on their old paycheck, and how going even one dollar over an income threshold can raise your premium for the whole year. They also walk through Form SSA-44, which lets you ask Social Security to use your current income if your situation has changed because of retirement, divorce or the loss of a pension.

Listen to Our Podcast On:

TIMESTAMPS

00:08 – 02:05 – Introduction

02:06 – 04:41 – Understanding IRMAA and Medicare Premiums

04:42 – 06:13 – How IRMAA Income Thresholds Work

06:14 – 08:06 – Requesting a Medicare Premium Adjustment with Form SSA-44

08:07 – 09:31 – Closing

Follow Us on Social Media

Stay updated with the latest episodes and news by following us on social media:

 

Episode Glossary

  • IRMAA (Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount): An additional charge added to Medicare premiums for individuals with income above certain thresholds.

Key Takeaways

  • Your Medicare premium is generally based on your tax return from two years ago. Your 2026 premium, for example, usually looks at the income on your 2024 return.
  • That means someone who retired recently can still pay a surcharge based on a paycheck they no longer receive.
  • The standard Medicare Part B premium for 2026 is $202.90 per month. Higher earners can pay an extra amount on top, called IRMAA (Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount).
  • IRMAA works like a cliff, not a tax bracket. Going over a threshold by even one dollar raises your premium for the entire year.
  • For a single filer, reporting $109,001 instead of $109,000 could cost about $1,148 more for the year. If both spouses are on Medicare, it could be roughly $2,297 more for the household.
  • If your income has dropped because of a life-changing event like retirement, divorce or the loss of a pension, you can ask Social Security to use your current income with Form SSA-44. If it’s approved, the difference can be credited or refunded.
  • Because premiums often come straight out of your Social Security check, you may not notice you’re paying more. Don’t assume the number on your premium notice is the final word.

Transcript

Not Just Numbers: Honest Conversations with a Financial Advisor and Lawyer
Episode 87 – Why Is My Medicare Premium So High? Understanding IRMAA and the Two-Year Lookback

Introduction

Madison: Hello everyone and welcome to Not Just Numbers, Honest Conversations with a Financial Advisor and Lawyer, the official podcast of Yardley Wealth Management. I am Madison Demora and I am here with Mike Garry. Mike is a financial advisor and a CFP practitioner and the founder and the CEO of Yardley Wealth Management. He is also an estate planning lawyer, and his law firm is Yardley Estate Planning. Hey Mike.

Mike: Hey Maddie, how are you?

Madison: I’m good. How are you doing today?

Mike: Good.

Madison: All right, so Mike, I want to start today’s conversation with a situation that I think could surprise a lot of people approaching retirement. Imagine someone who recently enrolled in Medicare. They received their first premium notice, and the amount is much higher than they expected. But here’s the confusing part: they haven’t done anything differently this year. Why would their Medicare premium be so much higher than they anticipated?

Mike: Well, Maddie, that is actually something that catches a lot of retirees off guard. What people don’t realize is that their Medicare premium isn’t necessarily based on what they’re earning today; it’s based on their tax return from two years ago.

Madison: So someone could be retired now, no longer receiving a paycheck, but Medicare is still looking at that income they earned when they were working?

Mike: Exactly, you could be retired, living off your savings today, and still paying a Medicare surcharge based on a paycheck you stopped collecting years ago. And for someone who just transitioned to retirement, that could be a pretty significant difference.

Madison: Which is interesting because you would think that once your income drops in retirement, your Medicare premiums would reflect that change.

Mike: You would think so, but that’s not necessarily how the system works. And that’s why it’s important for people to understand these rules before they enroll in Medicare.

Understanding IRMAA and Medicare Premiums

Madison: So today, we’re going to break down how Medicare’s two-year lookback works, where the biggest surprises happen, and what you can do if that old tax return no longer reflects your life. Mike, let’s start with the basics. When someone enrolls in Medicare, what should they expect to pay for their monthly premium?

Mike: Well, most people are familiar with Medicare Part B, which generally covers doctor visits, outpatient care, and other medical services. In 2026, the standard Medicare Part B premium is $202.90 per month.

Madison: And that’s already increased almost 10% from last year. Is that right?

Mike: Correct. But for higher earners, there’s another number that can get added on top. It’s called IRMAA, which stands for Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount. I’ve heard a million people say IRMAA. I bet five of them could say Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount is what it is.

Madison: IRMAA is much simpler. So essentially, depending on how much someone earns, they could be paying more for the same Medicare coverage?

Mike: Exactly. And the important thing to understand is that Medicare generally isn’t looking at your income right now. It’s looking backwards.

Madison: And that’s where the two-year lookback comes into play?

Mike: Right. For example, your Medicare premiums in 2026 are generally based on the income reported on your 2024 federal tax return.

Madison: So let’s say someone was earning a pretty high salary in 2024, but then they retired in 2025. Now they’re in 2026, their income has dropped substantially, and they’re primarily living off their savings. Medicare would still be looking at what they earned back in 2024?

Mike: That’s exactly right. Medicare is still basing that premium on their income from when they were working. So what their income looks like on paper can be completely different from their financial situation today.

Madison: And I imagine that’s where some retirees get caught off guard, especially if they’re expecting their expenses to go down once they stop working.

Mike: Yep. And that two-year lookback isn’t a new rule. It’s been around for years. But for many people, the first time they really experience its impact is when they enroll in Medicare and see what they’re actually going to be paying. You know, it’s one of those things that, you know, people anticipate throughout their life, right? You know that 65 Medicare starts, but you know until you go through… There are a lot of these things in life that until you go through them, you really can’t anticipate all that there is to them. And Medicare is one of those things. And so that’s why we’re trying to spread a little bit of knowledge and information for people out there that haven’t gone through it yet.

Madison: That’s right. So this is something people really need to consider before retirement, not just when they’re enrolling in Medicare.

Mike: Right. Understanding how your income today could affect your Medicare premiums two years from now is an important part of retirement planning.

How IRMAA Income Thresholds Work

Madison: All right, Mike. So there’s another part of IRMAA that I think people might find surprising, and that’s how the income threshold works. Can you explain that?

Mike: Sure. With income taxes, you know, we have marginal brackets, so we’re used to thinking in brackets, and when you move into a higher tax bracket, only the income above that threshold gets taxed at that higher rate, which is how taxes should work, but they don’t always. And IRMAA doesn’t work that way.

Madison: So how is it different?

Mike: So IRMAA is a cliff. If your income crosses one of the thresholds, even by a dollar, your Medicare premium jumps for the entire year.

Madison: Just one dollar? Can you give me an example of how much that could actually cost someone?

Mike: Absolutely. A single filer reporting $109,001 of income instead of $109,000 could end up paying about $1,148 more for the year.

Madison: So just because their income was one dollar over that threshold, they could pay almost $1,150 more for the year?

Mike: Yep.

Madison: And what about married couples? Does it work the same way?

Mike: Yeah. If both spouses are enrolled in Medicare, the same joint tax return affects both of their premiums. So crossing the applicable threshold could mean roughly $2,297 more for the household.

Madison: That’s a pretty dramatic increase, especially when we’re talking about crossing a threshold by one dollar.

Mike: You know, it really is. And the frustrating part, I think for a lot of people, is they don’t even know these cliffs exist until they’re already paying the higher premiums.

Requesting a Medicare Premium Adjustment with Form SSA-44

Madison: So Mike, let’s say someone is listening to this and realizes their Medicare premium is based on income they were earning two years ago. But since then they’ve retired, and their income has dropped significantly. Are they just stuck paying that higher premium?

Mike: Not necessarily. There is actually a form designed for situations like this called Form SSA-44.

Madison: And what exactly does that form do?

Mike: It allows you to request that Social Security consider your more current income instead of relying solely on your tax return from two years ago.

Madison: So when would someone qualify to use this form?

Mike: They can qualify to use the form if your income has dropped because of a qualifying life-changing event, such as retirement, divorce, or the loss of a pension.

Madison: Okay, so let’s say someone recently retired and submits this form. What happens next?

Mike: Well, it can take, not surprisingly, it can take several weeks for Social Security to process the request. And during that time, your premium stays at the original amount. But if the adjustment is approved, the difference can be credited or refunded.

Madison: Which is a lot better than just accepting a higher premium because Medicare is looking at income you earned two years ago.

Mike: Yeah. And the surprising or sad thing is that a lot of people don’t even know this option exists. This is something we have to explain to a lot of people.

Madison: And I imagine some people might not even realize how much they’re paying in Medicare premiums, especially if it’s automatically being deducted from their Social Security check.

Mike: That’s right. Because the premium often comes directly out of your Social Security benefits, you may not even notice what’s happening.

Madison: So essentially, someone could be paying more than they need to without ever feeling like they’re actively paying a separate bill.

Mike: Exactly, and that’s why it’s important to understand how your Medicare premiums are calculated and what options you may have if your financial situation has changed.

Closing

Madison: So, Mike, if there’s one thing you want people to take away from today’s conversation, what would it be?

Mike: So, I would say that don’t automatically assume that the number on your Medicare premium notice is the final word. Remember, that amount is generally based on a snapshot of your financial situation from two years ago. And your life today may look very different from what it did back then.

Madison: And someone’s financial situation today could look completely different from what it did back then.

Mike: Right. I mean, for most people, we think about this it’s because they retired and so their income is different. But you know, if you lost a pension or got divorced or or some other qualifying life-changing event, it certainly is worth your time to fill out the form and submit it.

Madison: So it’s important to understand how those changes could affect your Medicare premiums and whether you might qualify for an adjustment.

Mike: Absolutely. Because sometimes simply knowing the rules can make a pretty significant financial difference.

Madison: And that’s exactly why we wanted to have this conversation today. Thanks, Mike, and thanks everybody for listening. For more information on Yardley Wealth Management or Yardley Estate Planning, you could visit our websites at yardleywealth.net and yardleyestate.net. You can also follow us on socials at Yardley Wealth Management. Don’t forget to subscribe to our YouTube channel and smash the like button. This podcast has been produced by Madison Demora and Mike Garry with technical and artistic help from Poe Productions.

Request the Full Transcript as a PDF

The full transcript of this episode is available via email. Please fill out the form below to receive it: